If you’re anything like me, you love the look of a roaring fire, but you absolutely dread the maintenance—or worse, the heating bill that comes with an old gas unit. That’s why electric fireplaces have become so popular. They are incredibly safe, look surprisingly real, and offer fantastic zone heating.
- Key Takeaways: Our Top Picks
- Comparison Table
- Dimplex Revillusion 36
- Touchstone Sideline Elite 50
- Napoleon Alluravision Deep 60: The Best Energy Efficient Electric Fireplace for Large Rooms
- Dimplex Opti-Myst Pro 1000
- PuraFlame Alice 50 Inch Recessed
- Final Thoughts on Choosing Your Efficient Fireplace
- Frequently Asked Questions (FAQ)
When I redesigned my living room last year, the number one priority was minimizing energy usage. I found that installing a high-quality electric unit allowed me to dial down the central thermostat by almost four degrees in the winter! That’s real savings, folks.
We’ve tested the top units on the market right now to find the ones that deliver maximum comfort with minimum power draw. Here are the very best electric fireplaces designed with efficiency in mind.
Key Takeaways: Our Top Picks
- Best Overall Realism: Dimplex Revillusion 36 (It’s shocking how good this insert looks.)
- Best Wall Mount/Recessed Value: Touchstone Sideline Elite 50 (Perfect blend of features and price point.)
- Best Efficiency for Large Spaces: Napoleon Alluravision Deep 60 (Superior zonal heating for bigger rooms.)
- Most Cutting-Edge Tech: Dimplex Opti-Myst Pro 1000 (Uses water vapor for flames—zero heat energy usage unless you flip on the heater.)
Comparison Table
| Model | Type | Size (Approx.) | BTUs (Max) | Best For |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Dimplex Revillusion 36 | Firebox Insert | 36 Inches | 5,118 BTUs | Replacing an old wood/gas unit. |
| Touchstone Sideline Elite 50 | Recessed/Wall Mount | 50 Inches | 5,000 BTUs | Standard living rooms and DIY installation. |
| Napoleon Alluravision Deep 60 | Recessed/Wall Mount | 60 Inches | 9,000 BTUs (High Heat Setting) | Large, open-concept spaces requiring real zonal warmth. |
| Dimplex Opti-Myst Pro 1000 | Built-in/Cassette | 40 Inches | 4,400 BTUs (Optional Heater) | High-end commercial or custom residential projects. |
| PuraFlame Alice 50 Inch Recessed | Recessed/Wall Mount | 50 Inches | 5,000 BTUs | Budget-conscious buyers needing a sleek look. |
Dimplex Revillusion 36
If you have an existing fireplace opening that you want to fill without going through the messy demolition of a traditional unit, the Dimplex Revillusion 36 is an absolute winner. This is the unit I often recommend to clients who prioritize realism above all else.
Dimplex has patented technology here that makes the logs look scorched and the backdrop mirrors the flames, making them appear deeper and more random than typical electric units. Crucially for efficiency, the heater is a powerful fan-forced ceramic unit, but it’s positioned to push the warmth directly out into the room (zone heating) instead of losing it up a chimney or radiating inefficiently.
Pro Tip: These insert units are fantastic for capturing the classic aesthetic. If you want maximum efficiency, make sure your old chimney flue is sealed and insulated above the unit so you aren’t fighting cold air coming down into the room.
Who This Is For
Homeowners replacing a drafty gas or wood fire, or those who want the absolute most realistic traditional log appearance without using gas.
Touchstone Sideline Elite 50
The Touchstone Sideline series is the workhorse of the recessed electric fireplace world. The Elite 50 is their upgraded model, offering better interior components and more viewing angles for the flame effects—all while maintaining excellent heat efficiency.
What I appreciate about this unit is the straightforward installation. It’s designed to be fully recessed into a 2×4 wall, so you get that perfectly flush, modern look that screams custom installation. The heater is centrally located and uses a high-velocity fan to quickly warm up a medium-sized room (around 400 sq ft).
Who This Is For
The majority of homeowners looking for a quality, recessed wall-mount unit that balances visual appeal, heating ability, and price point perfectly. This is the best all-around value.
Napoleon Alluravision Deep 60: The Best Energy Efficient Electric Fireplace for Large Rooms
When you need big heat and big visuals, you turn to Napoleon. The Alluravision Deep 60 lives up to its name, providing a much deeper firebox than typical flat-screen models. This means the log set looks far more substantial, and the flames have more room to dance, enhancing the 3D effect.
But let’s talk about why this is an excellent energy efficient electric fireplace. This unit is capable of outputting up to 9,000 BTUs on its 240V setting (though it can run on standard 120V at 5,000 BTUs). This higher wattage rating means it heats a significantly larger space—up to 800 sq ft—much faster. Rapid, focused heating is key to efficiency, as you don’t have to run the heater for as long to achieve comfort. If you have an open kitchen/living area, this model ensures you use far less power than cranking your central HVAC.
Who This Is For
Anyone with large or open-concept living spaces who needs a serious, premium zonal heating solution combined with high-end, contemporary style.
Dimplex Opti-Myst Pro 1000
Okay, prepare to be amazed. The Opti-Myst Pro 1000 isn’t just an electric fireplace; it’s a technological marvel. Instead of relying on LED screens or reflections, this unit uses ultrasonic technology to create a fine mist of water vapor. LEDs shine onto the mist, making it look exactly like smoke and fire. You can literally reach your hand through the flames!
From an efficiency standpoint, this is the gold standard because it produces no heat unless you install the optional heater component. The energy draw is just for the lights and the mist generator, which is minimal. If your primary goal is ambiance and hyper-realism without needing any supplemental heat, this is untouchable.
Note: This is a sophisticated cassette system often used in commercial settings or high-end residential custom builds. It requires a water line connection, so installation is more complex than a standard plug-in unit.
Who This Is For
Luxury builders, designers, or consumers prioritizing 3D realism and zero-heat operation. Ideal for climates where heat isn’t necessary but ambiance is crucial.
PuraFlame Alice 50 Inch Recessed
Sometimes you just need a straightforward, good-looking fireplace that fits your budget without sacrificing too much quality. That’s where the PuraFlame Alice 50 comes in. While it doesn’t have the hyper-realism of a Dimplex or the power output of the Napoleon, it delivers the sleek, recessed look that everyone loves.
Like most standard electric units, it provides around 5,000 BTUs of supplemental heat, which is perfect for zone heating a 400 sq ft room. The running costs are extremely low when used without the heater (just for the lights), and even when the heater is running, it performs similarly to other basic units—meaning you’re still saving money compared to gas or oil.
Who This Is For
First-time electric fireplace buyers, budget renovators, or anyone needing a simple, reliable, attractive unit for a smaller space.
Final Thoughts on Choosing Your Efficient Fireplace
Picking an energy efficient electric fireplace really boils down to balancing your desired level of realism with your heating needs. If you’re filling an old hole, the Dimplex Revillusion is a must-see. If you need serious heat for a big room, the Napoleon is worth the investment.
Remember, the efficiency of these units isn’t just about the technology inside; it’s about how you use them. Electric fireplaces are designed for zone heating. You should never try to heat your entire house with one! Instead, focus on keeping your primary living space warm and comfortable while lowering the central thermostat for the rest of the house.
You’ll love the cozy atmosphere and even more, you’ll love seeing the difference on your monthly utility statement!
Frequently Asked Questions (FAQ)
How much does it cost to run an energy efficient electric fireplace?
Running costs vary based on local electricity rates. Generally, running the flame effect only (without heat) costs just pennies per hour, usually less than 5 cents. Running the heater element at full power usually costs between 15 and 25 cents per hour, similar to running a small space heater. Because the heating is focused, however, the overall daily cost is usually much lower than using central HVAC.
Are electric fireplaces actually safe?
Yes, they are extremely safe. Unlike traditional fireplaces, there are no open flames, no dangerous combustion byproducts (like carbon monoxide), and no hot coals. Many units feature cool-touch glass or are designed so that the heat output is well-insulated, making them a great choice for homes with kids or pets.
Do I need ventilation or venting for an electric fireplace?
No, electric fireplaces are completely vent-free. They do not burn fuel or create smoke, making installation simpler and keeping all the heat generated right in your room (another huge bonus for efficiency).
Leave a Reply